Best Crib Mattresses

The Best Baby Mattress Reviews

It is no surprise that babies spend most of their first year of life sleeping as they rapidly develop and experience growth spurts. It is for this reason that a safe and comfortable mattress for a baby to lie on is so important. Although it may seem challenging to find the perfect mattress for your baby, our reviews below are here to help you navigate through some of the best crib mattresses available on the market today.

Here are the recommended best crib mattresses:

How to Choose a Crib Mattress

There are a few key things to keep in mind while shopping for a crib mattress. There should be a certain level of quality sought after throughout the process. Cheaper-quality mattresses are not only uncomfortable to sleep on but may also pose serious health-related problems. Some of these mattresses are coated in powders or built with materials that later emanate from the mattress or become loose. In doing so, these loose particles can pose serious health-hazards to a sleeping baby. The quality of material that makes up a mattress should be one of the most important factors when selecting a crib mattress.

Another thing to keep in mind is that good quality mattresses are typically covered with thick laminate or organic cotton, making it less likely for a baby to puncture through the padding. A thicker cover also tends to last longer than a thinner, low-quality one. Maintenance of laminate or organic cotton covers tends to be easier as they are either stain-resistant or machine washable.

One other thing to look for is how flimsy a crib mattress appears to be. If the mattress flops around easily, it may not be comfortable or safe to sleep on. Keep in mind that the price of a product may also be misleading. An expensive mattress does not always guarantee better quality. Always be sure to check the mattress for flimsiness regardless of the posted price.

Reasons Why to Purchase a Quality Crib Mattress

There are obvious comfort and health-related reasons to purchase a quality crib mattress. First and foremost, you want a long-lasting mattress to make the most use of it. If you own a baby crib that can later be turned into a child’s bed, then you will likely use the same size mattress for a while. Only a good quality mattress will stand the test of time and be used for several years without a problem,

But, let’s not forget how important a baby’s comfort is. Most of a baby’s first year of life is spent sleeping. A flimsy, cheap mattress might not hold up to a baby’s sleeping patterns. A comfortable, good-quality mattress can help ensure a baby gets the good rest he or she needs.

Best Type of Inside Support

nnerspring. Innerspring mattresses are lovely to sleep on as long as they are made with enough padding. Cheaper models are made with fewer springs, which make the mattress weak, susceptible to breaking down, and uncomfortable. The key is to go with a high-quality innerspring option.

An alternative to innerspring mattresses is foam mattresses. Memory foam mattresses are comfortable and breathe better than other options. Foam mattresses outline the body to provide support. However, once the foam has shaped itself to fit the positioning of your body, it can be difficult to alter your positions. The original outline stays in place for some time, and it can take a bit of time for the new outline to be formed. Understandably, this situation can cause some mild discomfort.

Therefore, purchasing a foam crib mattress depends on the type of movement a baby makes through the night. If the baby stays relatively in one position, then it might not be so uncomfortable. On the other hand, foam mattresses are known for holding body temperature rather well, so this factor must also be taken into consideration at the time of purchase.

Price Comparisons

When it comes to looking at the price differences between these two types of mattresses, parents will be surprised to find out that they are rather similar. Most quality innerspring and foam crib mattresses range between $90.00 and $1,500.00 dollars. Surprisingly, most of the crib mattresses can be found at quality construction slightly above the baseline price for both types of mattresses.

Description of Best Crib Mattresses

Below you will find a review of each aforementioned crib mattresses to give you a better understanding of their value.

Babies have a tendency to make a mess in their cribs from time to time. Even though this design from Newton comes with highly breathable mattress cover options, the mattress is also easily cleaned. Parents can actually take off the mattress cover and throw it in the washing machine when needed. Therefore, cleaning away messes or sweat and dust mites is an easy task. However, dust mites shouldn’t be an issue, to begin with, because this mattress is hypoallergenic.
Both toddlers and infants can make use of this bed. If you have a crib that can be transformed into a toddler bed, you can continue using this mattress and not have to worry about purchasing another one.

Simmons is known for making great adult mattresses, but only a few people realize they also make a version for children as well. This mattress is comfortable and durable. Unlike the other models mentioned, this mattress includes 231 pocketed coil springs for balanced support throughout the night. This mattress also includes a protection border and inner foam corner protection. These two features prevent a baby from rolling into a crib corner or onto their side where they might accidentally suffocate throughout the night. Additionally, the woven cover on this mattress is double sided. One side is designed for newborns as it is firmer, and the other side is designed for toddlers.

“My First” mattress is made out of hypoallergenic material, which minimizes the threat of dust mites and bed bugs, and CertiPUR-US certified flexible polyurethane foam for comfort. This mattress fits all standard sized cribs and can also be used in toddler beds. The mattress cover is waterproof, meaning any spilled liquids will stay in a localized place for easy cleaning. The mattress cover is removable and machine washable.

“Colgate Eco Classica III” mattress is made out breathable organic cotton. This model features orthopedic support that will leave baby feeling extremely comfortable for nights on end. Considering the amount of time baby will spend on this mattress, parents will be happy with the results of each night’s sleep. It does offer dual firmness for infants and exceptional comfort for toddlers. The certified organic cotton cover sits on top of a waterproof backing, making it great for all of the life’s little messes that baby might make.

For parents wanting an organic cotton cover on their baby’s crib mattress, they might want to consider Naturepedic’s model. It has two-stages of dual firmness that can hardly be found in any other mattress. This mattress is also double-sided. One side is designed for the use of babies because it is firmer, while the other side is designed for the purpose of a toddler. However, toddlers who enjoy a firmer mattress can continue to use the firmer for an extended period of time as well. This mattress is waterproof and can be easily wiped cleaned. It also includes Certi-PUR US patented foam, making it a very comfortable mattress for a baby.


There are plenty of crib mattresses out there that will keep a baby healthy and happy. However, the “My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress” stands high above all others. This mattress has all the features parents could want in a baby mattress. One of its best features is the Certi-PUR US certified foam, which makes this mattress very comfortable to sleep on. With the different firmness options, babies can grow into this mattress as well. Although each model mentioned satisfies standards of quality and comfort, the “My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress” is one of the best options. However, parents will be pleased with any of the options mentioned in this list.

Our Mattress Guides